By Harris Allgeier
Staff Columnist
9 a.m. The checkpoint opens. I wipe the sweat off my brow and lift the iron shutter, bellowing a monotone “NEXT!” into the PA system. A woman approaches; she’s elderly. She wants entry for two weeks to visit her dying son. Her passport information is correct, she has all the appropriate vouchers, I prepare my green “accepted” stamp when I notice out of the corner of my eye a discrepancy in the seal on her entry permit. I circle it with my pen and point out the error. She breaks down, sobbing. Through her tears she blubbers out that she sold all her possessions to obtain a forged permit on the black market. She just wants to see her son. I prepare the stamp. A large red “rejected” is pressed onto the paper. I call the guards to escort her away. The next man has a clearly forged ID; the picture doesn’t even resemble him. He offers me a bribe of 20 credits. I let him through. Such is life in glorious Arstotzka.
This is but one hour of a day in “Papers, Please,” the brainchild of independent developer Lucas Pope, a quirky, bleak puzzle game for the PC wherein you play as a newly-installed immigration officer in the fictional communist bloc country of Arstotzka. The meat of the gameplay in “Papers, Please” consists of receiving potential immigrants, checking over their paperwork, and deciding whether or not they meet the qualifications to enter the country. Each day is time-limited, and the more people you correctly process the more money you make. At the end of every day, you’re required to allocate your money to pay for the food, housing, and medical expenses of your family.
Playing “Papers, Please” isn’t immediately engrossing; the interface is in some ways deliberately cumbersome, the discrepancies you’re on the lookout for aren’t always apparent, and the story seems broad and distant. However, spend a few minutes acclimating, and you’ll start to slip into a rhythm, scanning documents, checking references, and stamping. The story starts to take shape gradually and in many different forms. There are the small stories, the little vignettes of each potential immigrant that begin with pleas of acceptance end when you bring down the all-powerful stamp. Then there is the larger story involving an anti-government conspiracy, terrorist bombings, international and ethnic tensions, and the fate of your family. One of the best parts of “Papers, Please” is the pliability of the story. The game features 20 potential endings; the choices that bring you to the end are brilliantly integrated. While some potential choices may have obvious implications, many are impossible to spot or predict until after you’ve made them. Some you may not realize you’ve made at all.
The true power of “Papers, Please” lies in the exploration of morality. In most games that offer a kind of moral choice, the paths are clearly presented. You can kill a man or save him, return the stolen goods or keep them for yourself. Straightforward. “Papers, Please” presents a much grayer dichotomy. Will you accept bribes from the guards to unnecessarily detain and interrogate people? If you don’t, you’ll spare a few innocent lives unnecessary pain, but if you do you can maybe get enough money to afford that operation your son has desperately needed for weeks. That’s the insidious brilliance of “Papers, Please.” Evil isn’t a maniacal plan to take over the world; it’s a wealth of small wrongs, tiny sleights that make unbearable lives just a little easier. It’s not hard, it’s easy, and it happens every hour, every day. “Papers, Please” may not make you squeal with glee, or gape-mouthed in wonder, but it will make you think carefully about your choices in a way more powerful than any bombastic, triple-A release in recent memory.
